Haven't had an automatic in a Jeep, but did have one in a Bronco. It was my hunting vehicle so it was 4 wheeled a lot. My opinion of as automatic for 4 wheeling ...Hated it, hated it, hated it. Especially in low range. Why? Low range felt the same as high range. How could that be? The automatic would shift right up through the gears into over drive and felt the same that is unless the trans. was manually shifted down. I never felt I had the control of a manual transmission. Yes, I know it's popular to go with an Automatic, but the reason fails me. Did I say that I hated the automatic for 4 wheeling........