Before the gas crunch the factories would often put in very low gearing.
Don't get used gears. Randy's Ring and Pinion is a good source of gears and axle parts:
http://www.ringpinion.com/
They are very knowledgeable and will make sure you get the correct parts.
Here's a chart to help get the correct gearing.
This shows the tire size vs. gear ratios. The numbers in the middle are the engine RPM at 65 mph. Shoot for gearing in the green for the best compromise between power and mileage. You may even consider going slightly into the yellow for high gas mileage. Red is low gearing but I would stay away from those gear ratios unless the jeep is only for off road (not street legal)
Then the YJ and the Cherokee has a high pinion. The HP gears are cut differently.
The teeth of all ring and pinion gears have a drive side and a coast side. Theses teeth are angled so the drive side of the gear is stronger. Because of this the low pinion is stronger in the rear and HP gears are stronger in the front.